Skip to content

How to Choose Car Insurance That Fits Your Vehicle and Budget

Choosing car insurance often comes down to clauses that most drivers only read after an accident. Two factors determine…

Femme comparant des offres d'assurance auto sur ordinateur portable avec des documents sur une table en bois

Choosing car insurance often comes down to clauses that most drivers only read after an accident. Two factors determine whether a policy is right for you: how it calculates compensation in the event of a total loss, and how the deductible compares with the vehicle’s actual value.

Rising costs for spare parts and labor are pushing premiums up, even for drivers with no claims, as insurers spread the growing cost of repairs across their entire customer base.

Economically irreparable vehicles: how your policy calculates compensation

A vehicle is declared economically irreparable when the cost of repairs exceeds its replacement value as assessed by an expert. This is common after structural damage to an older combustion-engine model. It can happen much sooner with an electric car: damage to the battery pack may be enough to exceed the vehicle’s market value.

Compensation then depends on the valuation clause in your policy. Three methods are commonly used:

  • Replacement value as assessed by an expert (VRADE), calculated using the Argus valuation guide or by an appointed expert, taking the vehicle’s age, mileage and condition into account. This is the default under comprehensive coverage.
  • New-for-old value, available as an optional extra, which reimburses the vehicle’s purchase price for a limited period (often two to three years). This cover does not apply unless the policy explicitly includes this clause.
  • Agreed value, set by the policyholder and insurer when the policy is taken out. It protects classic cars and vehicles with high depreciation, but comes with a higher premium.

When an electric car’s battery is damaged, things get more complicated. If the battery is leased, the insurer may refuse to include it in the compensation calculation because it is not part of the policyholder’s assets. If it is owned, the replacement cost may account for most of the vehicle’s value. We recommend checking whether the policy includes a specific battery cover clause before signing.

Comparing compensation terms across insurers, including through car insurance on Annu Moteurs, can help you identify policies that explicitly cover the battery as a component in its own right.

Man standing beside his car and checking a car insurance app on his phone

Electric car insurance: cover to check beyond comprehensive coverage

Taking out comprehensive insurance for an electric vehicle is not enough to cover the risks specific to this type of powertrain. Cover for the battery, charging cable and running out of charge varies from one insurer to another, and these items are not always included in standard cover.

Battery and charging cable

Some policies exclude leased batteries from damage cover. Others cover owned batteries but cap compensation below the actual replacement cost. Charging cables, which are often stolen or damaged in public places, may be covered under theft and vandalism cover or as a separate optional extra.

A home charging station is generally covered by home insurance, not car insurance. Electrical damage to the charging station (such as a power surge or fire) will not be covered by your car insurance, even if you have comprehensive cover.

Running out of charge and towing

Running out of battery on a highway is not treated like a conventional mechanical breakdown. The vehicle cannot be recharged on the spot and must be towed to a compatible charging station. Some roadside assistance policies limit towing to a distance that may not be enough to reach a fast-charging station. Checking the towing distance included in your assistance cover is a detail that is often overlooked.

Manufacturer’s warranty and insurance

A manufacturer’s warranty that covers the battery for several years on a new vehicle can affect the level of insurance you need. For a used electric vehicle whose manufacturer’s warranty has expired, the need for battery cover increases accordingly. Adjusting your policy when buying a used car helps you avoid paying a premium for a risk already covered by the manufacturer—or, conversely, being underinsured.

Deductible and premium: balancing monthly costs against out-of-pocket expenses

The deductible determines the actual cost of a claim for the policyholder, not just the premium. A low-premium policy with an €800 deductible will cost more after your first minor accident than a slightly more expensive policy with a €300 deductible.

The right way to assess it is to compare the deductible with the vehicle’s value. For a car worth €5,000, a €1,000 deductible represents 20% of its value. For a vehicle worth €25,000, the same deductible amounts to just 4%. The lower the vehicle’s value, the lower the deductible needs to be for insurance to remain worthwhile.

Young man meeting with a car insurance adviser to choose a policy that fits his budget

Another often underestimated factor is the contribution for natural and technological disasters, whose rate for car insurance policies rose from 6% to 9% on January 1, 2025. This regulatory charge is non-negotiable and is added to the base premium. It is not always clearly shown in online quotes, which can distort comparisons if you only look at the amount before tax.

Canceling and switching car insurance: an underused way to save

After the first year of a policy, you can cancel a car insurance policy that renews automatically at any time. Your new insurer will handle the process to ensure there is no gap in cover. This makes regular comparisons worthwhile, especially after changing vehicles, changing how you use your car or seeing your no-claims discount change.

Comparing policies whenever your circumstances change can help you benefit from price differences based on your updated profile. A driver who switches to remote work and reduces their annual mileage may be able to secure a significant reduction by declaring their new usage. Switching from a combustion-engine vehicle to an electric one also changes the pricing structure at most insurers.

Your no-claims bonus remains the most powerful individual factor affecting your premium. We find that many drivers do not realize that this rating follows the driver, not the vehicle: changing cars does not reset it, and neither does changing insurers.

The right policy is not the one that costs the least when you take it out. It is the one whose compensation terms, deductible and specific cover match the vehicle’s actual value and how you use it. In a market where repair costs are driving premiums up, reading the policy schedule remains the only reliable way to compare cover.

How to Choose Car Insurance That Fits Your Vehicle and Budget